Field note N° 02 · Reconciliation

When the photo and the drawing disagree

Every experienced engineer has opened a panel and found that the installed equipment is not what the drawing says it is. The drawing shows the design. The field shows forty years of repairs, replacements, and additions — some documented, most not.

The common cases are mundane. A breaker failed at some point and was replaced with a different trip rating; the drawing was never updated. A transformer was swapped during an outage and the replacement has a different impedance. A panel schedule was typed up from the drawing set years ago, so it repeats the drawing's version of the truth, including the parts that were never built that way. Redlines from a renovation sat in a job folder and never made it back into the master set. None of this requires carelessness. It only requires time.

Neither source wins automatically. The photo is the better evidence for what is installed: the breaker frame you can see, the nameplate you can read. The drawing is the better evidence for what a photo cannot show: conductor runs inside conduit, lengths, equipment in rooms nobody photographed, the intended topology of the system. Treating the drawing as truth imports every stale value in the set. Treating the photo as truth throws away everything outside the frame. The disagreement itself is the information — it marks a place where someone has to decide, on the record.

That decision belongs to the engineer, and it has to be made value by value. A conflict on a main breaker's trip rating changes a study. A conflict on a panel's label text does not. The work is not resolving every difference; it is seeing all of them clearly enough to judge which ones matter, and recording what was decided so the next engineer does not have to re-litigate it.

What ElecProof does: when the extracted value from a photo and the value on the drawing differ, both are shown side by side, each linked to its source — the photo and the drawing, not a summary of either. The conflict is flagged for your reviewer, who decides which value stands. The decision is recorded with the study. Nothing is averaged, reconciled silently, or overwritten to make the model look clean.

More field notes

ElecProof turns field photos and old drawings into a verified draft model — every value linked to its source. See pilot pricing.